Soil Report Review & Permit Support

Common Problems With Geotechnical Reports in Ontario

A geotechnical report can look complete on the surface but still fail to answer the question that matters for a permit, foundation design, retaining wall, addition, underpinning project, or construction decision.

This guide explains the most common problems with geotechnical reports in Ontario, including unclear bearing capacity, missing foundation recommendations, outdated reports, insufficient boreholes, groundwater concerns, fill issues, and reports that do not match the submitted drawings.

Report Adequacy Bearing Capacity Issues Permit Comment Problems

Request Soil Report Review Call 416-822-6643

Quick Answer

Common geotechnical report problems include missing or unclear bearing capacity recommendations, insufficient borehole coverage, groundwater not being addressed, fill or unsuitable soil being overlooked, recommendations that do not match the drawings, outdated reports, unclear limitations, and reports that do not respond directly to a city or structural engineer’s comment.

If you already have a report and are unsure whether it is adequate, see our Soil Report Review in Ontario page.

Why Geotechnical Report Problems Matter

A geotechnical report is often used by structural engineers, architects, designers, contractors, municipalities, owners, and developers to make decisions about foundations, footings, bearing capacity, excavation, groundwater, retaining walls, slopes, drainage, and construction risk.

If the report is unclear or incomplete, the result can be more than confusion. It can lead to permit delays, redesigns, construction disputes, unexpected costs, or unnecessary back-and-forth between the owner, engineer, contractor, and city.

The issue is not always that the report is “bad.” Sometimes the report was prepared for a different purpose, earlier design, different area of the site, or limited scope. Other times, the report may contain useful information but does not clearly connect that information to the permit comment or current drawings.

That is why report adequacy should be judged against the actual project, not just the number of pages in the report.

Concerned about an existing report?

Send the report, drawings, and the specific concern. We can review whether the report appears to address the issue or whether clarification, supplemental work, or a new investigation may be needed.

Request Report Review

Problem 1: The Report Does Not Match the Current Project

One of the most common problems is a mismatch between the geotechnical report and the current drawings. A report may have been prepared for an earlier concept, a different footprint, a different foundation layout, or a smaller scope of work.

This becomes a problem when the current project involves:

A city reviewer or structural engineer may question whether the report still applies. If the report does not cover the current work, a clarification letter, addendum, supplemental investigation, or new report may be required.

Problem 2: Bearing Capacity Is Missing, Unclear, or Not Project-Specific

Bearing capacity is one of the most important parts of many small-building geotechnical reports. The structural engineer may need an allowable bearing pressure for footings, foundations, additions, underpinning, retaining walls, or other structural elements.

Problems occur when:

If bearing capacity is the main concern, review our Soil Bearing Capacity Testing in Ontario page and Understanding Soil Bearing Capacity.

Problem 3: Borehole Locations or Depths Are Not Adequate

A report can include boreholes and still be questioned if those boreholes do not properly represent the proposed work area. Borehole location and depth matter because soil conditions can vary across a property.

This becomes a concern when:

The city or structural engineer may request more information if the report does not provide enough confidence for the area being built on.

Problem 4: Groundwater and Drainage Are Not Properly Addressed

Groundwater can affect excavation, foundation construction, basement performance, retaining walls, drainage, and construction cost. A report that mentions water but does not explain its implications can create uncertainty for designers and contractors.

Groundwater-related report problems include:

Related articles: Water Near Foundation and Soil Investigation and High Groundwater Table and Foundation Concerns.

Problem 5: Fill or Unsuitable Soil Is Mentioned but Not Clearly Resolved

Fill, organic material, buried debris, soft soil, loose material, or disturbed ground can significantly affect foundation support. A geotechnical report should usually explain how unsuitable materials should be handled if they affect the proposed foundation or structure.

Common fill-related problems include:

Fill-related uncertainty is one of the situations where a report review can be valuable before responding to the city or starting construction.

Problem 6: Recommendations Are Too General

A report may include standard language but still fail to provide project-specific guidance. This can be frustrating because the report may appear complete but not answer the practical question the owner, designer, contractor, or reviewer is asking.

General recommendations may be a problem when:

The best geotechnical reports are not just technical. They are usable by the project team.

Problem 7: The Report Does Not Address the City Comment

A municipality may ask for a specific geotechnical item, but the submitted report may not answer that item directly. This can happen even if the report contains useful technical information.

For example, the city may ask for:

If the report does not clearly respond to the comment, the permit may remain delayed. See City Rejected Your Soil Report in Ontario? for a more focused guide on this situation.

Problem 8: The Report Is Old or Being Reused Incorrectly

Reusing an existing soil report can save time in some cases, but it can also create problems if the report does not apply to the current project.

An old report may be questioned if:

Related guide: Can a Soil Report Be Reused in Ontario?

Problem 9: Limitations and Assumptions Are Ignored

Geotechnical reports usually include limitations. These limitations matter. They may describe what the report was prepared for, what drawings were reviewed, what assumptions were made, and what conditions must be verified during construction.

Problems occur when:

Many report problems come from using a report beyond its intended purpose.

Problem 10: The Report Creates Expensive Recommendations Without Clear Explanation

Some geotechnical recommendations can significantly increase cost. These may include removal of unsuitable material, engineered fill, deeper foundations, groundwater control, retaining wall measures, slope review, or supplemental investigation.

Expensive recommendations are not automatically wrong. But the report should make it possible to understand why the recommendation was made and how it relates to the observed site conditions.

If the cost impact is significant, a second opinion may help clarify:

Related article: Second Opinion on a Geotechnical Report in Ontario

Signs You Should Request a Soil Report Review

You may want a report review if any of the following apply:

For review support, visit Soil Report Review in Ontario.

Need a report reviewed before responding to the city?

Send the soil report, drawings, permit comments, and your concern. We can review whether the issue appears to require clarification, an addendum, supplemental testing, or a new report.

Request Soil Report Review

Can These Problems Delay a Building Permit?

Yes. If a geotechnical report does not answer the reviewer’s question, the city may pause the review until the issue is resolved. The delay can become worse if the project team resubmits the same information without addressing the specific comment.

Permit delays often occur when:

For the main service page, see Soil Testing for Building Permit in Ontario.

How to Avoid Geotechnical Report Problems

The best way to avoid problems is to define the scope correctly before the investigation begins. The geotechnical engineer should understand the project type, proposed foundation, permit requirements, retaining walls, grade changes, basement work, and site constraints.

Before ordering a report, provide:

For process details, see Geotechnical Investigation Process in Ontario and What Is Included in a Soil Report?.

Related Resources

Need Help Reviewing a Geotechnical Report?

Send us the report, drawings, permit comments, and your specific concern. We can review whether the report appears to address the project or whether clarification, supplemental work, or a new investigation may be needed.

Request Soil Report Review


Frequently Asked Questions

What are common problems with geotechnical reports?

Common problems include unclear bearing capacity recommendations, missing foundation guidance, insufficient borehole coverage, outdated reports, reports that do not match the current drawings, lack of groundwater or fill discussion, unclear limitations, and recommendations that do not address the city or structural engineer’s comment.

Can a poor geotechnical report delay a building permit?

Yes. If the report does not address the permit reviewer’s specific concerns, the city may request clarification, a revised report, supplemental investigation, or additional foundation recommendations before continuing the review.

What should I do if my geotechnical report seems incomplete?

First compare the report with the drawings, permit comments, and proposed construction. If the concern remains, request clarification from the original engineer or obtain an independent soil report review to determine whether additional information or new testing may be required.

Does an unclear geotechnical report always require new testing?

No. Some issues can be addressed with clarification, an addendum, or a response letter. New testing may be required if the report lacks relevant boreholes, does not cover the proposed work area, is outdated, or does not include the information needed for the permit or design.

Can I get a second opinion on a geotechnical report?

Yes. A second opinion can help identify whether the report appears suitable for the project, whether recommendations are clear, whether the city comment is addressed, and whether clarification, supplemental work, or a new report may be appropriate.